We’ve all had that heart-stopping moment. Your phone slips, tumbles, and lands with a sickening clatter. The dread of picking it up to see the damage is a feeling nobody enjoys.

While the internet is full of DIY tricks for how to remove scratches from a phone screen, the truth is, most of them are a bit of a gamble. Before you start rummaging in the bathroom cabinet for toothpaste, let's talk about what actually works and what could make things worse.

It's More Than Just a Scratch

That one blemish on your screen is never just a cosmetic flaw, is it? It’s that annoying line that catches the light every single time you look at your phone. It can mess with the touchscreen's responsiveness, ruin the picture when you're trying to watch a video, and seriously knock down what your phone is worth if you ever decide to sell it.

These things happen to everyone. It doesn’t matter if you're on the train from Merstham or walking through Redhill town centre. A set of keys in the wrong pocket or a simple slip from the sofa is all it takes to mark that once-perfect glass.

A Problem Across the UK

You're definitely not alone in this. Damaged screens are a massive headache for millions of us, and it can be a real hit to the wallet.

In fact, recent research found that a whopping 24% of UK smartphone users have broken their screen in just the last two years. That figure nearly doubles to a staggering 48% for people aged 16-24. It seems some places are clumsier than others, too! Londoners top the charts for breakages, while here in the South East, we're a bit luckier, with the figure sitting around 19%. You can dig into more of these smartphone damage trends if you're curious.

Let’s be honest: once your screen has a deep or noticeable scratch, the only real fix is a professional repair or a full screen replacement. But these can be shockingly expensive, often costing so much that it just doesn't make financial sense.

This guide is here to give you the straight story. We'll touch on a couple of home remedies that might help with the tiniest of scuffs, but more importantly, we’ll help you figure out when it's time to stop trying and look at other options.

Sometimes, the smartest move isn't a repair at all—it's trading in that damaged phone for cash. If your screen is looking a bit worse for wear and you're wondering what to do next, you can find out exactly what it's worth with us at EXE. Just fill out our simple sales form for an instant, no-strings-attached quote.

Figuring Out the Damage: Light Scuff or Deep Gouge?

Before you start raiding the cupboards for a magic fix, let's figure out what you're actually dealing with. Not all scratches are created equal, and the difference between a faint scuff and a deep gouge will dictate your next move. Get this part wrong, and you could end up making things worse.

First, give your screen a proper clean. A soft, clean microfibre cloth is your best friend here. Get rid of any dust, grime, or fingerprints, as smudges can easily make tiny scratches look like the Grand Canyon.

Once it's spotless, find a bright, direct light source—a desk lamp or even the torch on another phone works wonders. Tilt your phone back and forth, letting the light catch on any imperfections. This is where you play detective.

The Fingernail Test: Your Scratch Severity Guide

You're essentially looking for one of three types of damage. The easiest way to tell them apart is the good old-fashioned fingernail test.

  • Micro-scratches: These are the little guys. You can barely see them unless the light hits just right, and you certainly can't feel them when you run your finger over the screen.
  • Light Scratches: You can just feel these with your fingernail, but it glides over them without getting stuck. They're annoying and visible in most lighting, often caused by jangling around with keys or coins.
  • Deep Scratches or Gouges: This is the big one. Your fingernail will physically catch in the groove. They're obvious to the naked eye, might distort the display underneath, and feel rough to the touch. This kind of damage can easily turn into a full-blown crack.

To help you visualise the best course of action, I've put together this quick table.

Scratch Severity and Your Best Options

Scratch TypeHow to Identify ItRecommended Action
Micro-scratchesOnly visible under direct light. Cannot be felt with a fingernail.Often hidden by a new screen protector. DIY polishing compounds may work, but proceed with extreme caution.
Light ScratchesVisible in normal light. Your fingernail can feel the groove but doesn't get caught.DIY methods are risky and unlikely to work. A high-quality screen protector is your best bet to hide it.
Deep ScratchesVery easy to see. Your fingernail snags in the groove. It may distort the screen's image.DIY is a no-go. This needs professional screen repair or a full replacement.

As you can see, your options shrink pretty quickly as the scratch gets deeper, moving from "maybe I can fix this" to "I need to call in the experts."

A flowchart detailing a step-by-step process for assessing and repairing phone screen scratches, from DIY to professional help.

It’s no surprise that smashed screens are such a common headache. In fact, damaged screens account for a staggering 36% of all smartphone damage incidents reported across the UK, making it the top problem by a country mile. It’s simple physics, really; modern glass still struggles against a drop from your pocket onto a hard pavement. You can read the full research on smartphone damage if you're curious about the stats.

If your assessment reveals a deep gouge rather than a minor scuff, a professional repair can be expensive. Before you commit, it might be worth seeing what the phone is worth as it is. For a quick and fair alternative, you can always get an instant quote from us. Just pop your details into our sales form to find out.

Do Those DIY Scratch Removal Tricks Actually Work?

If you've ever typed "how to remove scratches from phone screen" into a search bar, you've probably been hit with a tidal wave of DIY hacks. Everyone seems to have a secret weapon hiding in their bathroom cabinet or kitchen cupboard, from toothpaste to baking soda. They all promise a cheap, magical fix for your scuffed-up screen.

But let's get real for a moment. Do any of them actually work? And more importantly, could you end up doing more harm than good?

Before we go any further, a word of warning: these home remedies are only for the faintest, most superficial micro-scratches. We're talking about those tiny marks you can only see when the light hits them just right. If you can feel the scratch with your fingernail, stop right there. A DIY fix is not the answer and will almost certainly make things look a lot worse.

Hands polishing a scratched smartphone screen with a cloth and white cream to remove marks.

The Truth About Toothpaste and Baking Soda

The most popular suggestions you'll see are toothpaste (the plain old white paste, not the gel stuff) and a slurry made from baking soda and water. The idea is that these are mild abrasives that can gently sand down the screen's surface until the scratch vanishes.

It sounds plausible, but there’s a big problem with this logic. Your phone screen isn't just a simple piece of glass; it has an invisible layer on top called an oleophobic coating. This is what works wonders to repel fingerprint smudges and gives the screen its smooth, slick feel.

Here’s the Catch: When you rub an abrasive—any abrasive—on your screen, you're not just polishing the glass. You're grinding away that essential oleophobic coating. You might make a tiny scratch slightly less noticeable, but you'll likely create a dull, smudgy patch that’s a magnet for fingerprints, making your screen look far worse overall.

If you’re dead set on giving it a go, please be careful. Always switch your phone off completely. Crucially, take the time to meticulously tape over every port, button, speaker, and seam. The last thing you want is for paste or moisture to seep inside and cause irreversible damage. Use a tiny dab on a clean microfibre cloth, rub the scratch with very gentle, circular motions for a minute, then wipe it clean with a separate, slightly damp cloth.

What About Car Polish Compounds?

Another "hack" you might come across is using car scratch removal creams. The thinking here is that if it works on a car's paintwork, it should work on a phone. People often try all sorts of materials to fix scuffs, much like in a DIY guide on removing scratches from different surfaces.

But a car's clear coat and a phone's highly specialised glass are two completely different beasts. These compounds are often far too aggressive for a delicate screen and bring all the same risks as toothpaste, but cranked up to ten.

  • You'll strip the oleophobic coating: This isn't a risk; it's practically a guarantee.
  • You could create more scratches: Some compounds have particles coarse enough to create a permanent haze of fine new scratches all over the screen.
  • You'll get an uneven finish: It is incredibly difficult to get a consistent, factory-polished look by hand, leaving you with a patchy mess.

At the end of the day, trying to buff out scratches with these methods is a massive gamble, and frankly, the odds aren't good. The potential for making things worse is just too high.

For those in Redhill or nearby areas like Merstham with a phone that’s looking a bit tired, a professional repair is an option, but it can be surprisingly expensive. Before you fork out for a new screen, think about a smarter alternative. Find out what your scratched phone is actually worth by getting a quick, no-pressure quote from us. Just pop your details into our sales form and get a fair price today.

When a DIY Fix Just Won't Cut It

So, you’ve given the gentle buffing a go, held your breath, and… the scratch is still there, staring right back at you. Let's be honest, sometimes a home remedy simply isn’t going to be enough.

Here’s a simple test from someone who's seen it all: if you can run your fingernail over the screen and it catches in the groove, the damage is too deep for any DIY polish to sort out. At this point, you’re really looking at two main paths: a professional screen repair or a full-on screen replacement.

Professional Repair: Weighing Up Your Options

This is where things can get expensive, and fast. Your first big decision is where to take your phone for surgery. You can go straight to the source, like Apple or Samsung, for an official repair. This guarantees you'll get genuine parts and top-notch workmanship, but it's almost always the priciest route.

The other option is to check out a local, third-party repair shop. If you’re around Redhill or nearby places like Merstham, you'll find plenty of independent shops. They can often get the job done quicker and for less cash. The catch? The quality of the parts can be a bit of a lottery, so you'll want to find a trusted technician to avoid more problems down the road.

The Staggering Cost of a New Screen

For many people, the real shock comes when they see the price tag for a new screen, especially on newer phones. The cost of fixing screen damage in the UK has shot up to frankly eye-watering levels. For a flagship model, like one of the latest iPhones, you could easily be looking at a bill from £279 to over £389 for an official replacement. You can read more about the challenges facing the UK mobile phone repair industry if you're curious.

When a single repair costs a massive chunk of what the phone is actually worth, you really have to stop and ask if it's a smart move. Pouring hundreds of pounds into a device that might already be a couple of years old often just doesn't make financial sense.

Is the Repair Truly Worth It?

Before you book that expensive repair, take a moment and do a quick bit of maths. What’s your phone currently worth in good nick? Now, take the cost of the repair away from that number. The figure you're left with might be surprisingly low, showing that the "fix" is actually a pretty poor investment.

This is the exact point where a much smarter, more practical alternative comes into play. Instead of spending your money fixing an old device, why not get paid for it instead—scratches and all?

Before you commit to a repair, find out what your phone is worth as-is. You can get an instant, no-strings-attached quote by filling out our simple sales form. You might just discover a much better option.

The Smart Alternative: Sell Your Scratched Phone for Cash

After looking at the eye-watering cost and faff of a professional repair, a lot of people come to the same conclusion: it’s just not worth it. Pouring a couple of hundred quid into fixing a phone that’s already a few years old doesn't really add up.

So, what’s the smarter move? Instead of spending money to fix it, why not make some money from it?

This is where selling your phone, scratches and all, becomes a brilliant alternative. Forget the stress of repairs. At EXE, we specialise in buying phones in any condition, so a few scratches are no problem for us. You get instant cash for your device, just as it is.

A person's hand places a smartphone with a cracked screen on a wooden counter next to a repair quote and another phone.

A Simple and Fair Process

We know you just want a fair price without the hassle, so we’ve made our process incredibly straightforward.

Here’s how it works:

  • Get a free quote online: In just a couple of minutes, you can see exactly what your phone is worth. It’s completely free, with no obligation.
  • Arrange a convenient collection: If you’re near us in Redhill or in surrounding towns like Merstham (within a six-mile radius), we can pop over to your home or office to collect the device.
  • Receive instant payment: Once we’ve given the phone a quick check, we make an immediate bank transfer. Often, the money is in your account before our team has even left.

Selling your phone to us means you skip the repair saga entirely. You get a fair price for your damaged device and can put that cash towards a brand-new, flawless phone.

Every single device we handle undergoes a secure, GDPR-compliant data wipe. This gives you complete peace of mind that your personal information is safe. It’s a secure, fast, and profitable way to deal with a scratched-up phone.

What If Selling Isn't For You?

We get it. Sometimes you just want to clear out old tech. If selling isn't on the cards or you want an eco-friendly option for a much older, less valuable device, you could look into how to recycle electronics with a free pick up service. It’s a great way to ensure your old gadgets are disposed of responsibly.

But for a device that still has some life in it, even with a scratched screen, getting paid is usually the best move.

Ready to see what your phone is really worth? Fill out our simple sales form for your free quote now.

Keeping Your Next Phone Screen Flawless

After the hassle of dealing with a scratched screen, you’ll definitely want to avoid a repeat performance. Honestly, the best way to fix a scratch is to stop it from happening in the first place. A little prevention now saves a massive headache down the line.

It all boils down to a couple of smart, simple investments for your new device. A quality screen protector and a good case are your absolute best friends in the fight against everyday scuffs and surprise drops.

Choose Your Screen Armour Wisely

When you’re browsing for screen protectors, you'll mainly come across two types: thin plastic films and much tougher tempered glass.

  • Tempered Glass: This is what we always recommend. It feels just like your phone’s actual screen, keeps the display crystal clear, and offers far better protection against both scratches and impacts. A good one will even sacrifice itself—shattering on a hard drop to save the expensive screen underneath.

  • Plastic Film: These are cheaper and thinner, but they really only protect against the most minor scuffs. They tend to scratch up easily themselves and don’t offer any real defence if you drop your phone.

Think of a good tempered glass protector as a small price to pay for some serious peace of mind.

The Power of a Protective Case

Your next line of defence is a solid case. The single most important feature to look for here is a raised lip (or bezel) that goes around the screen's edge.

This tiny design feature is a game-changer. It means that when you place your phone face-down on a table, the glass itself never actually touches the surface. It’s an incredibly simple idea that prevents countless micro-scratches from building up over time.

It’s also about building good habits. The number one cause of screen scratches is sharing a pocket with keys, coins, or other sharp metal objects. Just designate one pocket for your phone—it’s a tiny change that makes a huge difference.

Ultimately, keeping your screen pristine is the best way to maintain your phone’s value. When it’s finally time to upgrade, a device in great condition will always fetch a better price. And if you do decide to sell, you know who to call. Get a great price for your old tech by filling out our easy sales form.

Got Questions About Phone Scratches? We’ve Got Answers

Still on the fence about what to do with your scratched-up screen? That’s completely understandable. Let’s tackle a couple of the most common questions we hear all the time.

Does Toothpaste Really Get Rid of Phone Scratches?

Ah, the old toothpaste trick. You’ve probably seen this one all over the internet. The short answer is: it’s a massive gamble.

Because toothpaste is a mild abrasive, it can sometimes seem to buff out the tiniest of surface-level scuffs. The reality, though, is that you’re just as likely to strip away your screen’s protective oleophobic coating, which can lead to even more problems. For anything deeper than a hairline mark, it often just makes the damage more obvious. Honestly, we’d steer clear of this one.

Is it Cheaper to Repair a Screen or Just Sell the Phone?

This really comes down to the phone you have and just how bad the damage is. If you're using a newer, top-of-the-line model, a professional screen replacement can easily cost a few hundred pounds.

In a lot of situations, you'll find it makes more financial sense to sell the phone as-is and put that cash towards an upgrade. You get a decent return without the hassle and expense of a repair.


At EXE, we help take the guesswork out of that decision. If you're around Redhill, Merstham, or the local area and you're wondering what to do, why not get a free, no-pressure quote from us first? You might be pleasantly surprised at what your scratched phone is still worth.

Ready to see for yourself? Just pop your details into our simple sales form and get an instant price today.